How to Make a Simple Sourdough Starter

How to Make a Simple Sourdough Starter
A sourdough starter is nothing more than flour and water left to its own devices, yet it becomes a living thing on your worktop — a colony of wild yeasts and friendly bacteria that will raise loaf after loaf for years. There is no packet yeast involved and no great expense. What it needs is patience, a bit of warmth, and a regular habit of feeding. Start one this week and by next weekend you could be pulling a proper crusty loaf from the oven, or frying tangy pancakes for a Sunday breakfast.

What You Actually Need

  • A clear glass jar, roughly 500ml to 1 litre, with a wide mouth. You want to see what is happening inside without guessing.
  • Digital scales that measure in 1g increments. Cups are hopeless here.
  • Flour. Strong white bread flour does the heavy lifting, but add a spoonful of wholemeal or rye — the bran and germ carry far more wild yeast, and a rye starter gets going noticeably faster.
  • Water. Most UK tap water is fine, but if yours smells strongly of chlorine, draw a jug and leave it covered overnight so the chlorine disperses.
  • A warm spot at around 21–24C. The airing cupboard in January, the kitchen worktop in July. Your starter is sensitive to temperature, and a cold snap will slow it right down.

The First Four Days

Day one: weigh 50g wholemeal flour and 50g warm water into your jar — around 30C, tepid rather than hot. Stir into a thick, lumpy paste, scrape down the sides, and rest a lid on top without sealing it tight. The mixture needs to breathe.

Day two, you may see a few bubbles and a faint beery smell. Stir it and leave it. Day three brings the first proper feed: tip away half of what is in the jar, then add 50g strong white flour and 50g water. Stir well, and from here on feed it once a day at roughly the same time.

Expect a burst of activity on days two or three, followed by an unnervingly quiet stretch around days four to six. That is the normal rhythm — the first flush of easy bacteria dies back as the sourdough-friendly ones take hold. Keep feeding. It will come back with far more vigour.

Feeding It Well

The simplest ratio is equal weights of starter, flour and water, so a 100g starter gets 100g flour and 100g water. This keeps it at 100% hydration, a thick batter consistency that is easy to judge by eye.

Discarding half before each feed matters more than people expect. Without it, the jar fills up within a week, the food runs out and the culture turns sour and sluggish. Keep the discards in a separate jar in the fridge; they are far too useful to bin.

Once your starter is reliably doubling, you can move to a larger ratio — one part starter to two or five parts flour and water — which gives it more food and buys you time between feeds. A fridge starter only needs feeding once a week, which suits most working kitchens.

Reading the Signs

  • Doubled in four to six hours, domed on top, faintly sour and slightly yeasty: ready to bake.
  • Grey liquid pooling on top — this is hooch. It means hunger. Pour it off or stir it in, then feed.
  • Nail varnish or acetone smell: very hungry indeed. Pour off the hooch and give it a generous feed.
  • Pink, orange or fuzzy patches, or anything mouldy: throw it out and begin again. No salvaging this one.
  • Thin, watery and no rise: usually cold or underfed. Move it somewhere warmer and feed twice daily for a few days.

Waking It Up for Baking

A starter from the fridge needs coaxing. Take it out, feed it, and repeat two or three times over 24 hours until it rises predictably within four to six hours. The old float test — a spoonful dropped in water should bob — is a rough guide at best. Trust the rise and the smell instead.

Once active, a straightforward loaf is 500g strong white flour, 350g water, 100g lively starter and 10g salt. Mix, rest, fold every 30 minutes for a couple of hours, shape, prove overnight in the fridge, then bake hot and covered for the first twenty minutes.

Beyond the Loaf

The discard is where everyday cooking gets interesting. Whisk it into pancake batter with milk, an egg and a pinch of salt for breakfasts that taste faintly of yoghurt. Use it in crumpets, drop scones and Yorkshire puddings. It makes a wonderful pizza dough and lends depth to soda bread. Through autumn, fold grated apple and a spoonful of honey into a spelt loaf; in spring, a handful of wild garlic works beautifully.

Feed it, name it if you like, and keep it going. A jar of flour and water will quietly become the most useful thing in your kitchen.